I started obsessing over hangers because I wanted to have a pristine closet with uniform hangers that looked IDENTICAL. So I started researching, and came up with very little. The only posts I could find that compared clothes hangers seemed to be advertising their own product. Through trial and error, I finally found the perfect hangers for me – after trying two that didn’t work. I will outline all the details below (prices in Canadian dollars) and you can decide which option might work for you.
First I tried the IKEA BUMERANG hangers in white:
$6.99 for 8 hangers, making them $0.87 each.
Being made out of wood, these hangers had nice weight to them. They were not TOO expensive, and the white colour had a very clean minimalist feel. However, the hangers were not 100% identical. Some of them hung a little lower (maybe 1mm or so) and it drove me crazy. Also, they were a bit thick and difficult for my tiny closet to accommodate. And even though they’re pretty inexpensive, I needed about 60 of them, and $55.92+tax is not the world’s cheapest option. They’d have to be perfect. I ended up moving these hangers into the hall closet to use for coats. They make nice coat hangers.
Next I tried a higher class option. I had hoped that if I spent a little more money, I would be happier with the results. I purchased the Whitmor 6026-343 Natural Wood Collection Dress or Shirt Hanger, Set of 5 for $11.99, making them pretty pricey at $2.40 each. But hey, you get what you pay for, right?
Meh. I was pretty underwhelmed by these hangers. I was expecting perfection because they cost more than twice what the IKEA hangers cost. They were nice, but they were not PERFECT. And I demand perfection! Like the IKEA hangers, there were subtle differences that became apparent when I had ten of them hanging in a row – one might hang a millimetre lower, and that just drives me nuts. So I returned them. I will say that they shipped quickly and had a hassle-free return process. Worth a short if you think you might be less obsessive than me and don’t need to buy 60 (which would cost you $143.88+tax).
Don’t worry folks – this story has a happy ending! I kept my eyes peeled, and was determined to find hangers I could live with. I had wanted wooden hangers, but decided to broaden my horizons because wooden hangers seemed to have inconsistent manufacturing. Maybe cookie-cutter identical plastic hangers were the ones for me. (Note: I had considered the lovely black metal velvet hangers, but I’ve had them before and I don’t like the way some shirts cling TOO MUCH to the velvet and make it difficult to slide onto the hanger.)
I actually found the perfect hangers for me at WALMART, can you believe it? And the irony is that I must’ve bought these hangers at some point in my past, because I actually already had some! And they had been a favourite of mine for a time, but I would never have been able to recall where I bought them. May I present to you, dear reader, the Neatfreak 30 Pack W Clothes Hanger:
30 hangers for $7.77, making them a screamin’ good deal at $0.26 each. Heck yes.
I love these hangers because clothing goes on the hanger smoothly, and the shape doesn’t leave weird indents on the shoulders of my long-sleeved tops. I love that they’re inexpensive, so buying 60 only costs me $15.54+tax. I love that they’re lightweight yet feel solid, and most importantly… THEY ARE 100% IDENTICAL. This satisfies me immensely.
The only downside would be that they’re plastic, not wood, so you miss out on that lovely bit of aesthetic. Also these hangers are not suitable for heavy coats or full suits, because they will bend a bit and possibly snap. They’re perfect for your shirts and tops though.
There you have it! If you’re aware of a clothes hanger option that can beat these, please let me know. It’s been quite a journey but I am getting a lot of pleasure out of the result. You can think that’s weird, but you’re the one reading this post, aren’t you? 😉
Good luck on your own hanger search!